Credit Union Real Estate Decisions: The Same But Different
So, you want to expand your credit union. Across town. Across the state. Maybe even across the country.
Many CU’s do that, so how hard can it be? After all, you’ve done business in your state during times both good and bad and you know the lay-of-the-land: Its industries, politics and people.
So you begin the requisite expansion steps by making assumptions about future market growth and revenue projections. And since you’ve opened a few local branches in the past several years, you apply those real estate costs to your pro forma estimates. After all, how different could expenses be from one regional market to the next?
In a word: Very!
It Costs How Much?!?
Cost-wise, Tampa is different than Orlando. Minneapolis different from St. Paul. Sharing the same border, Orange County is vastly different than Riverside County. This is a reality that exists in every market and every state.
Prior to becoming our client, a small but growing credit union applied land purchase and construction costs from their current 400,000 population market to their proposed expansion into a 300,000-size market less than 90 miles away.
They under-budgeted by nearly 100%.
So close on a map but a world away cost-wise. The fact is, while commodities such as lumber, steel, glass and concrete may be similar, labor can vary wildly and the biggest difference of all – by far – is the cost of the real estate itself. Either to own or lease.
Example: When first creating their expansion plan, our client was looking at specific potential properties with an estimated cost per-square-foot (PSF) that they presented and “sold” to their board. Two years later, much of that inventory was no longer on the market and what was available was far more expensive. In short, while our client planned and then waited based on their pre-determined timeline, the real estate market didn’t care and it certainly didn’t wait.
The point being that, more than ever, real estate assumptions are a dynamic and constantly changing thing. As a result, development plans – to the extent possible – must be made on actual space in the actual market where you are planning to expand – not on a site in another market that you secured two years ago.
Finger in the Wind Versus Verifiable Facts
Based on experience, our opinion is that most static information presented by a majority of local brokers is not only inaccurate but an existential threat to your plans and future. For this reason, we created and leverage our proprietary market assessment and planning tool,
With databases from numerous sources being constantly updated, Rubicon Reveal enables us to provide our clients with timely and detailed research data on every U.S. market. The result is a powerful information tool with data ranging from current and projected labor costs all the way down to the price and availability of a ground lease pad at the corner of Main & Main.
Flexibility as a Competitive Advantage
Over the years, we have seen numerous credit unions with detailed timelines that were blessed by their Boards and not to be changed. But in the real world where properties appear and disappear from markets like real estate Whack-a-Mole, our counsel is to seize profitable opportunities when and where they arise.
Consider what happens when a well-located property suddenly becomes available at an attractive price. It checks all the right boxes in a market where you are planning to expand – but not for another year.
By being flexible, savvy credit unions will be nimble enough to call an audible, revise their timeline and take advantage of the opportunity (think land banking) – even if it’s out of sync with the original plan. As any military leader will tell you, the plan changes as soon as the operation begins.
This flexibility may then enable you to take action in 2023 instead of a year or more down the road. The result is a new branch chalked up in the “win column” even though it’s not where you originally planned.
Even in the face of inflation, rising interest rates, high commodity costs and labor shortages – strong opportunities still arise. Sometimes even better than anticipated. When they do, embrace flexibility and be sure your future plans are based on what is “now known” instead of “what was.”
Corey A. Waite is a leading commercial real estate advisor to the financial services industry. As Founder and CEO of Rubicon Concierge Real Estate Services, Corey works directly with senior executives coast-to-coast to deliver strategic plans and transactional services focused on optimizing the needs of employees, clients and members.
When it comes to the credit union industry, I never cease to be inspired by the many people I meet who are committed to making their organizations and communities stronger and more sustaining.
In addition to enhancing income and capital, a Sale/Leaseback transaction provides a “win-win” by enabling CUSO investors to achieve certain tax benefits that are unavailable to credit unions.
Silicon Valley Bank (and others), inflation, fed interest rates and future job uncertainty are all fueling concerns about and within the banking industry. Yet, in the face of all this uncertainty, credit unions and community banks are still expanding their branch networks. Why? And are they going about it in the right way?
Nearly every firm we know has — or is in the process — of evolving its workplaces in order to recruit and retain key talent and grow their business. See what one of the world’s leading consulting firms has to say on the matter.
A lot of smart people go deep to deliver powerful information and insights that can benefit your business. And the best leaders are those who carve out the time to find, consider and, if and when appropriate, employ what they’ve learned.
For all its angst, the pandemic has been a catalyst for change throughout the credit union industry. CU’s of all size are embracing innovation and re-considering everything … especially when it comes to design and purpose of their branches.
Expanding a real estate portfolio is a heavy lift for any credit union. Succeeding with an expansion initiative – and with your Board of Directors – requires some important and un-relenting disciplines.
In the race to anticipate the future and stay ahead of the competition, it’s important to recognize that the “next shiny thing” is not really what your members want most. What they want is satisfaction.
In the face of so much uncertainty, the key to future growth – if not survival — for many credit unions is through mergers and acquisitions. Often times, the ultimate success of am M&A transaction is based on the true value of the seller’s real estate portfolio – and this is where assessment and due diligence isn’t always what it should be.
The sticker shock rise in construction costs has many credit unions pulling back on their current project pipeline. While that makes sense, it doesn’t mean you have to suspend your overall growth plans.
Trying to make up for lost time (and commissions), the real estate industry is eager to have you make deals. After all, what could go wrong?
Growth is good for most credit unions, but funding it can be long and costly. But if you look at your real estate portfolio through a different lens, you may find hidden treasure to help accelerate and ensure long-term success.