Rx for Rising Construction Costs: Absolute Flexibility.
I read a lot about the financial services industry and the many factors that impact it – particularly from a real estate portfolio perspective. Recent hot topics range from operations and all-things-financial to market demographics, workspace planning and the remarkable changes taking place regarding workforces-at-large.
Keeping up on these topics (along with many others) is useful. But what I find to be even more valuable than reading is listening. Listening to our clients and absorbing the real world information, insights and concerns they regularly share with us.
Lately, much of what we’ve been hearing has been focused on the meteoric rise in construction costs and how that is impacting their growth plans.
For a number of our credit union clients, this “cost catapult” isn’t simply hand-wringing about overruns on individual projects, but how those higher costs – ranging from 25%-to-100% (or more) above original budget projections – are forcing many to re-consider their current project pipeline, not to mention their long-term growth strategy.
In the face of board-approved budgets based on historical construction costs, we know of numerous credit unions that have scaled back from five expansion projects to three. Others from three to one. Some have suspended their portfolio growth plans altogether.
Upon hearing this, we encourage our clients to think about alternatives that are available to them other than “full stop.” In short, we encourage them to think about “what if?” To consider how being adaptable and flexible can leave the door open to portfolio growth and a competitive edge, albeit differently than originally planned.
Five “What Ifs?”
1. Lease Instead
- While it’s always tempting to purchase land and develop from the ground up – re-think that. (This also includes buying an existing property and pouring large sums into system upgrades and re-modeling). This strategy – especially in de novo markets – was costly before and even more so now. Instead, we suggest leasing space, assess your resulting profitability and consider purchase and/or ground-up development at a later date.
2. Improve and Enhance
- Search for existing properties that require less tenant improvements costs (TI’s). The obvious solutions are prior banks – especially those with good public and signage visibility. Again, leasing over buying is always a major cost saver.
3. Do More with Less
- Re-consider the total size of your future branches and what you plan to put inside them. Not all branches need to serve the same purpose. Understand your members in a particular market and build out your future spaces to reflect what is specifically required expressly for them.
4. Move Your Market
- Established markets with mid-to-high household incomes are always the most costly. Use this time as an opportunity to consider expanding into lower cost markets, especially low-moderate income (LMI) communities that will greatly value your presence.
5. Convert Your Costly HQ into Future Growth
- These days it not only costs more to buy and build, it also costs more to own. Expenses for maintenance, upgrades, insurance, utilities, property taxes and more are all way up and are going to remain that way for the foreseeable future. For this reason, many of our CU clients are funding their future by selling their HQ’s, leasing even better space at a lower cost and using this un-locked liquidity to fund future expansion.
Slower Yes, Stopping No
So yes, construction costs are high and likely to remain that way. Not to mention the rising costs for professional services, labor and money itself. Waiting and hoping for near zero interest rates and low commodity material prices is just that – wishful thinking. Which, as we all know, is not a strategy.
As horrible as COVID-19 has been, the pandemic also proved how innovative businesses are when they let go of “what was” and pivot to what “can be.” Inflation and an impending recession are difficult but not existential deal breakers. They are, in fact, opportunities to re-visit prior plans and forge new ones.
It’s also helpful to understand that the real estate market traditionally lags behind the rest of the economy. i.e., real estate prices rise and fall slower than, say, steak and sedans. So adjustments in purchase prices, lease obligations and construction costs will take longer to adjust than most aspects of the economy.
All things considered, high construction costs are tough but it doesn’t mean you can’t continue to grow and thrive. It’s just that how you do it may be different than originally planned.
Corey A. Waite is the leading commercial real estate advisor to the credit union industry. As Founder and CEO of Rubicon Concierge Real Estate Services, Corey works directly with senior Credit Union leadership to deliver strategic plans and transactional services focused on headquarters and branch locations alike. With a clear understanding of the unique mission and challenges of the Credit Union industry, Rubicon’s expertise and service is truly unique and value-added. You can reach the Rubicon Team at +1 (213) 462-2810.
Flexibility as Fact Recently I was proud to be part of a panel for Filene Institute’s “So You Want to Talk About” webinar series. For this session, the “talk” was about the future of branches....
Prior to becoming our client, a small but growing credit union applied land purchase and construction costs from their current 400,000 population market…
Working as diligently and quickly as possible, we were able to get the first phase on track and reasonably on-schedule…
The way automobiles were unlikely to replace horses? The way streaming was unlikely to disrupt cable? The way e-tailing is unlikely to impact shopping malls?…
For those not familiar with it, Filene is arguably the single best research resource for the credit union industry and Rubicon is…
The other day, I was reading (yet another) “Office of the Future” report. This edition was published by one the real estate industry’s oldest and largest…
Mr. Messick describes three basic options for generating capital to fund future credit union growth. Clearly, per his title, he advocates for Option #3….
Tesla has figured out that they don’t need a vast real estate footprint to sell automobiles. All they need is a great product, well-trained…
Ms. Truhart’s goal is to both remind and inspire credit union leadership to support modernization of the Federal Credit Union Act….
Tsunami warnings were issued prompting major seaports from Japan to California – all of them already strained by the massive supply chain breakdown – to prepare for a possibly catastrophic event…
I read with interest this week about Well Fargo’s Banking Inclusion Initiative. A 10-year commitment to “accelerate un-banked individuals’ access…
In a world where seemingly everything is changing, it’s logical for credit unions to “stand pat” when it comes to their headquarters…